Chuck, you really are misreading me. What I was trying to say was no where near interesting enough to warrant further discussion, but let me try one more time so you don't leave this thread thinking I'm a complete knucklehead.
You said "I just don't think there's a lot of American made Wm & Mary furniture." and, by comparison to the Chippendale furniture made in this country during the Chippendale period you're probably right if you are considering only the sheer number of pieces made. Realistically, the poplulation during the William & Mary period was far smaller so it stands to reason that the number of pieces would be proportionally smaller.
Right.
What I took away from your statement was that very little, if any furniture was made in the Colonies during the William & Mary period.
NOOOO! I never said that! What I was saying is that there isn't a lot of it NOW. Here's the quote:
"I just don't think there's a lot of American made Wm & Mary furniture. I don't think we have good ways of distinguishing this sort of furniture since it remained unchanged for so long."
The point I was trying to make was about the difficulty present day furniture dealers have making attributions since so little American made William & Mary furniture is on the market today. So when one encounters a piece of furniture like the tavern table in the photo, I think it's more difficult to date that particular piece because we don't have this large number of tables with provenances dating to the Wm&Mary period that we can compare it against. To make matters more difficult, this style of table remained virtually unchanged in design and construction from at least 1690 to probably 1750 or later.
You wrote: "The same holds true for any other period. We are part of the Society of Period Furniture Makers. By definition we're making period furniture out of period but that doesn't negate the existence of the original pieces."
Leaving us aside, this ISN'T the case of period furniture in general. If you are following me, the distinction is important. Some furniture forms (of varying styles) WERE NOT produced for decades and decades. This makes dating them easier.
Here's the heart of it: When I see a table like the one in the picture, I'm not certain about when it was made. If you radio carbon dated it to 1820, I wouldn't be surprised. The mixture of woods, the finish, maybe even the hardware doesn't lock this piece down to 1690-1720 for me. Could be that old, or could be later.
That's all I was trying to say. By the way- Please don't interpret my responses as defensive in any way. I really defer to your experience on this subject, Chuck. I'm just writing to clarify my meaning, not to defend the veracity of my remarks. Feel free to tell me I'm wrong. That's a learning opportunity for me and all who read along.
Adam